Differences Between ArrayList and CopyOnWriteArrayList in Java

What is the difference between ArrayList and CopyOnWriteArrayList? Please compare and interpret from the perspective of source code

ArrayList and CopyOnWriteArrayList are both implementations of the List interface in Java, but they are designed for different use cases and have different performance characteristics, especially in concurrent environments. Below, I will compare the two from a source code perspective, highlighting their key differences.

1. Basic Characteristics

• ArrayList:

  • It is part of the Java Collections Framework and is not synchronized, meaning it is not thread-safe.
  • It allows for fast random access and is generally more efficient for single-threaded scenarios or when synchronization is handled externally.

• CopyOnWriteArrayList:

  • It is part of the java.util.concurrent package and is designed for concurrent access.
  • It is thread-safe and uses a copy-on-write strategy, which means that it creates a new copy of the underlying array whenever it is modified (e.g., when adding or removing elements).

2. Source Code Perspective

ArrayList

Here is a simplified version of the ArrayList class:

public class ArrayList<E> {
    private Object[] elementData; // Array to store elements
    private int size; // Number of elements in the list

    public ArrayList() {
        elementData = new Object[10]; // Initial capacity
    }

    public boolean add(E e) {
        ensureCapacity(size + 1); // Ensure capacity
        elementData[size++] = e; // Add element and increment size
        return true;
    }

    public E get(int index) {
        return (E) elementData[index]; // Return element at index
    }

    // Other methods like remove, size, etc.
}

CopyOnWriteArrayList

Here is a simplified version of the CopyOnWriteArrayList class:

public class CopyOnWriteArrayList<E> {
    private volatile Object[] array; // Underlying array
    private final ReentrantLock lock = new ReentrantLock(); // Lock for synchronization

    public CopyOnWriteArrayList() {
        array = new Object[0]; // Initial empty array
    }

    public boolean add(E e) {
        lock.lock(); // Acquire lock
        try {
            Object[] newArray = Arrays.copyOf(array, array.length + 1); // Create new array
            newArray[array.length] = e; // Add new element
            array = newArray; // Update reference
            return true;
        } finally {
            lock.unlock(); // Release lock
        }
    }

    public E get(int index) {
        return (E) array[index]; // Return element at index
    }

    // Other methods like remove, size, etc.
}

3. Key Differences

1. Synchronization:

   • ArrayList is not synchronized, which means it is not safe to use in a multi-threaded environment without external synchronization.
   • CopyOnWriteArrayList is synchronized and uses a locking mechanism to ensure thread safety.

2. Modification Strategy:

   • In ArrayList, modifications (like adding or removing elements) are done directly on the existing array.
   • In CopyOnWriteArrayList, modifications create a new copy of the array, which allows for safe iteration over the list while modifications are happening.

3. Performance:

   • ArrayList is generally faster for read and write operations in a single-threaded context.
   • CopyOnWriteArrayList is slower for write operations due to the overhead of copying the array, but it provides better performance for read operations in a concurrent context since readers do not block writers.

4. Use Cases:

   • Use ArrayList when you have a single-threaded application or when you can manage synchronization externally.
   • Use CopyOnWriteArrayList when you have a multi-threaded application where reads are more frequent than writes, and you want to avoid concurrent modification exceptions.

Conclusion

In summary, the choice between ArrayList and CopyOnWriteArrayList depends on the specific requirements of your application, particularly regarding concurrency and performance. Understanding their source code and behavior helps in making an informed decision.